top of page

Custom Cakes

Yes! We make custom dairy-free cakes in all kinds of flavors and colors for all occasions!

Custom Round Cake.png
Custom Sheet Cake.png

Basic Custom Cakes

from $22

  • Choose cake flavor, frosting and filling

  • 3 round and 3 rectangle sizes available

  • Decorations include balloons, flowers and text

Deluxe Custom Sheet Cake.png
Deluxe Custom Round Cake.png

Deluxe Custom Cakes

from $52

  • Choose cake flavor, frosting and filling

  • 3 round and 3 rectangle sizes available

  • 3 decoration tiers: custom shapes; fancy piping/colors; custom scene. 

Photo Cake.png
Photo Cookies.png

Photo Cakes & Cookies

from $41

  • Choose cake flavor

  • Vanilla frosting only

  • 1 round and 3 rectangle sizes available

  • Any full-color .jpg or .png printed on your cake

Basic Custom Cakes

​Put a personal touch on one of our handmade cakes. Choose your favorite cake flavor, frosting and filling, your favorite colors, and let us know what message you’d like us to write.

Deluxe Custom Cakes

Our talented cake artists are ready to turn your dreams into reality. From deep sea mermaids, to fancy piping and decorations, to playground fun, we’ll work with you to design a cake for any occasion.  Cakes are priced based on the time needed to produce them. We have three tiers for custom cake design. Please review the pictures below to get a sense of what kinds of decorations are included in each tier. Should your design needs require additional time, we will contact you to discuss.

Tiers and Pricing

  • Tier 1:  2-3 simple drawings, shapes or icons (boat, baseball bat, etc.)  included

  • Tier 2: Extra fancy piping,  lots of colors,  and/or 1-2 more elaborate images.  +$15

  • Tier 3:  Fully-themed cake with all the details. +$30

Custom Photo Cakes & Cookies

There is no limit to your creativity with our edible icing photo cakes! This is a great option if you want to feature a photograph of a loved one on the cake, a company logo, or a complex design or scene. Note that edible icing can only be printed on vanilla frosting (but you can still choose the flavor of the cake and the filling inside).

Options & Dimensions

  • Round cake - 8” round will cover the surface of 8” cake, edged with piped icing

  • ¼ sheet cake - Cake is 9x13". The edible icing rectangle (which is 8.5”x10.75”) will cover the surface of a quarter sheet cake, edged with piped icing. 

  • ½ sheet cake - Cake is 18”x12”. The edible icing rectangle (which is 8.5”x10.75”) will be centered on the surface of the cake, with some empty space around it. Both the icing image and the cake will also be edged with piping. 

  • Full sheet cake - Cake is 24”x18”. Edible icing rectangle (8.5”x10.75”) will be centered on the surface of the cake. Image will be edged with piping and the cake will also be edged with piping. It is possible to fit up to 4 icing sheets on a full sheet cake for an additional $15 each. Please contact us to discuss this option.

  • 3” round vanilla cookies - printed image will be centered on the 3” cookie and ringed with frosting. (Sold by the dozen – same picture on every cookie).

Our Cakes

Learn about the different sizes and flavors that we offer. Don't see what you need? Just call! We'll be happy to help you find what you need.

What Size Do I Need?

Round Cakes

  • 6" Round: 6 ppl max

  • 7" Round: 6-8 ppl

  • 8" Round: 8-10 ppl

Square Cakes

  • 1/4 Sheet: 15-18 ppl

  • 1/2 Sheet: 30-36 ppl

  • Full Sheet: 60-72 ppl

ROCFedNY half sheet cake.JPG
Mini Mocha Log.JPG
Cake Flavors
  • Chocolate

  • Vanilla

  • Carrot (round only)

  • Marble Chiffon (round only)

  • Seven Layer (rectangle only)

Frosting Flavors
  • Chocolate

  • Mocha

  • Orange

  • Vanilla

  • Vanilla Whip

  • Chocolate Whip

Fancy Valentines Cake.JPG
Seven Layer Cake.jpeg
Filling Flavors
  • Chocolate Custard

  • Apricot

  • Cherry

  • Chocolate

  • Lemon

  • Raspberry

  • Vanilla

Occasions
  • Birthday

  • Anniversary

  • Bar/Bat Mitzvah

  • Retirement

  • Bachelor/Bachelorette

  • Wedding

  • Graduation

  • Baby Shower / Naming / Bris

  • New Job

  • Just Because!

MC Uncle D.jpg

How to Order

To order online, click here.

(scroll down to the "Cake" section in the menu)

To order by phone or email, download our Custom Cake Order Form. Email your completed form to maleksbakery@hillelschool.org or call 585-461-1720 to order.

bottom of page